Best Sellers – My Story By Jackie Cohen

Skip to content

Enjoy 15% off your first order when you sign up for emails! Sign up.

Enjoy FREE SHIPPING on all domestic orders over $500

Search

FINE JEWELRY
NEW ARRIVALS
THE GEMMY CUFF
THE HANNAH COLLECTION
SALE
ABOUT

Account Search Cart

FINE JEWELRY
NEW ARRIVALS
THE GEMMY CUFF

Design your own heirloom

The Gemmy Cuff

One Cuff. Infinite Stories.
A bold, modern heirloom—handcrafted for your story—fully customizable in every way.
details & process→
THE HANNAH COLLECTION

JUDAICA

The Hannah Collection

Celebrate Jewish heritage with exclusive Judaica pieces, including our signature Hannah Star of David pendant. Inspired by a family journey of resilience and pride, each piece carries a timeless connection to history, faith and love.
Explore THE COLLECTION →
SALE
ABOUT

Our Story

ABOUT MY STORY FINE JEWELRY →

ABOUT JACKIE →

GIVING BACK & PHILANTHROPY→

Best Sellers

Our most-loved, most-gifted and most-shared styles—these are the pieces everyone’s talking about. Discover the My Story fan favorites that keep telling your stories—again and again. Beloved, beautiful and best-selling for a reason.

Sort by

Featured Best selling Alphabetically, A-Z Alphabetically, Z-A Price, low to high Price, high to low Date, old to new Date, new to old

Filters

Product type

Bracelets Demi-Fine Necklaces Rings

Birthstone

Aquamarine Blue Iolite Blue Sapphire Blue Topaz Citrine Diamond Emerald Garnet London Blue Topaz Mint Green Amethyst Moonstone Opal Peridot Pink Amethyst Pink Sapphire Pink Tourmaline Purple Amethyst Ruby Turquoise

Price

$

$

Metal Color

14k White Gold 14k Yellow Gold 14k Rose Gold Yellow Gold

Collection

Bailey Fiona Hannah Julia MAC

Sort by

Featured Best selling Alphabetically, A-Z Alphabetically, Z-A Price, low to high Price, high to low Date, old to new Date, new to old

Yellow gold beaded skinny band.

Rose gold beaded skinny band.

White gold beaded skinny band.

Bailey Thin Beaded Band

Regular price $695.00

White gold skinny band with large round blue sapphires and small round diamonds.

White gold skinny band with large round blue topaz's and small round diamonds.

White gold skinny band with large round diamonds and small round diamonds.

White gold skinny band with large round garnets and small round diamonds.

White gold skinny band with large round rubies and small round diamonds.

White gold skinny band with large round aquamarines and small round diamonds.

Rose gold skinny band with large round amethysts and small round diamonds.

Rose gold skinny band with large round moonstones and small round diamonds.

Rose gold skinny band with large round diamonds and small round diamonds.

Rose gold skinny band with large round pink tourmalines and small round diamonds.

Yellow gold skinny band with large round peridots and small round diamonds.

Yellow gold skinny band with large round citrines and small round diamonds.

Yellow gold skinny band with large round garnets and small round diamonds.

Yellow gold skinny band with large round emeralds and small round diamonds.

Yellow gold skinny band with large round rubies and small round diamonds.

Thin banned gold ring with round diamonds shown on finger with denim

Regular priceFrom $945.00

Yellow gold skinny band with citrine baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with an aquamarine baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a diamond baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with an emerald baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a ruby baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a sapphire baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with an amethyst baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with an aquamarine baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a pink tourmaline baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with an amethyst baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with an aquamarine baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a peridot baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a pink tourmaline baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a blue topaz baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a diamond baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Julia Birthstone Ring

Regular priceFrom $1,090.00

Yellow gold skinny band with a pear shaped pink tourmaline in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a pear shaped amethyst in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a pear shaped peridot in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a pear shaped citrine in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a pear shaped emerald in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a pear shaped aquamarine in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with pear shaped ruby in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a pear shaped blue topaz in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a pear shaped aquamarine in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a pear shaped emerald in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a pear shaped garnet in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a pear shaped sapphire in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a pear shaped amethyst in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a pear shaped pink tourmaline in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a pear shaped blue topaz in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a pear shaped sapphire in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a pear shaped emerald in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a pear shaped amethyst in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a pear shaped garnet in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a pear shaped ruby in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Layla Birthstone Ring

Regular priceFrom $1,100.00

White gold skinny band with a bezeled peridot baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with bezeled blue topaz baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled citrine baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled emerald baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled garnet baguette in the center and round diamonds on the side.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled amethyst baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled emerald baguette and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled blue topaz baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled sapphire baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled sapphire baguette in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Juliet Birthstone Ring

Regular priceFrom $1,155.00

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape garnet in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape aquamarine in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape turquoise in the center and round diamond on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape blue topaz in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape opal in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape sapphire in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape opal in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape turquoise in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape aquamarine in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Yellow gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape blue topaz in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Rose gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape opal in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

White gold skinny band with a bezeled pear shape sapphire in the center and round diamonds on the shank.

Lizzo Birthstone Ring

Regular priceFrom $1,200.00

Yellow gold skinny micro pave band with round diamonds.

White gold skinny micro pave band with round diamonds.

Rose gold skinny micro pave band with round diamonds.

assorted ring stacks with mae

Regular price $1,595.00

Yellow gold skinny band with round diamonds.

White gold skinny band with round diamonds.

Rose gold skinny band with round diamonds.

Thin banned ring with a row of diamonds beautifully stacked

Stacey Stacking Band

Regular price $1,495.00

Yellow gold wide band with fluting.

Rose gold wide band with fluting.

White gold wide band with fluting.

Fiona Carson Fluted Band

Regular price $1,195.00

Yellow gold mama necklace with fluting.

Rose gold mama necklace with fluting.

White gold mama necklace with fluting.

Fluted rose gold mama necklace layered with other mama necklaces and netural tones

Fiona Fluted Mama Necklace

Regular price $995.00

Yellow gold mama ring with fluting.

Rose gold mama ring with fluting.

White gold mama ring with fluting.

Fiona Fluted Mama Ring

Regular price $1,045.00

Stella Peace Necklace

Regular priceFrom $1,550.00

MAC Solitaire Ring

Regular price $2,450.00

MAC East-West Half Eternity Band

Regular price $2,350.00

Lizzo Wire Bangle Bracelet

Regular priceFrom $1,795.00

Fiona Engravable Bangle Bracelet

Regular price $3,800.00

Yellow gold fluted heart charm with diamond initials, a diamond bail and a paperclip chain.

Fiona Love Charm Necklace

Regular priceFrom $2,950.00

Yellow gold heart necklace with fluting and diamond initials in the center.

Rose gold heart necklace with fluting and diamond initials in the center.

Yellow gold heart necklace with fluting and diamond mama in the center.

Fiona Love Pendant Necklace

Regular price $3,395.00

Large Jaime Star of David Dog Tag Necklace (Sapphire Crystals)

Regular price $180.00

Small Hannah Star of David Necklace

Regular priceFrom $1,800.00

Large Hannah Star of David Necklace

Regular priceFrom $3,600.00

50% off 1 in stock

Paloma 'R' Charm Necklace in Rainbow

Sale price $3,497.50 Regular price $6,995.00

50% off 1 in stock

Lizzo Wire Bangle Bracelet Pink Tourmaline 14k Yellow Gold

Sale price $897.50 Regular price $1,795.00

Large Jaime Star of David Dog Tag Necklace (Turquoise)

Regular price $180.00

Facebook
Instagram

Shop

Necklaces
Chains
Charms
Rings
Earrings
Bracelets
Gift Cards

Help Center

Contact Us
FAQs
Where To Buy
Shipping
Refund Policy
Terms of Service

site credit

© 2025 My Story By Jackie Cohen.

Your cart

Checkout

Your cart is empty

Start shopping